Dobby death reddit. I'm 24 freaking years old bawling and eating pizza rolls over the death "During the Battle of Hogwarts, the house-elves fought against the Death Eaters with Kreacher leading them. Dobby's death did nothing for the storyline at all. Dobby's death in the film. For me Dobby's death was the saddest because he lived most of his life in painful servitude and he was even stabbed to death which is very painful. I'm kinda neutral about this. Hate him across the board in the movies. When Dobby first Apparates into the dungeon at Malfoy Manor, he is shaking and his voice quivers. I can see why people would like him, but I can also see why people wouldn't. In movie canon Harry hasn't seen Dobby in about 5 years (8 years real life time). But in the books, Dobby is there for many important scenes. Mar 26, 2023 · As stated above, Dobby was an innocent soul that was lost in the shuffle of the struggle between good and evil. His death was the only time I cried when I first read Deathly Hallows. I’m indifferent to book Dobby save for CoS. Because he broke his promise he was punished with death. Dobby risked his life over and over to help good wizards. Suggesting making them invisible also, maybe giving Dobby the money to buy a few dozen Prompt Dobby keeps trying to keep Harry from going to Hogwarts because he knows about Lucius Malfoy's plan to plant the diary on one of the Weasley kids and have the monster released. I'm currently reading the book for the first time & he's just as annoying there. Goddamn physical knife attack killed him despite magical healing being a thing. but I love the scene where Harry says "Don't try to save my life again" and Dobby just smiles, that was so cute. But Dobby's death was much more intense in the book. Dobby shows up after they leave to mourne Harry's death, and out of sheer house elf magic willpower, his tears now unexpectingly bring Harry back to life. He was bitten by a giant snake. For me, Dobby's death was completely overplayed. But I still cried about Dobby. Where do you stand on Dobby: fantastic friend, or annoying distraction? Yeah, if I hadn't read the books, I doubt Dobby's death would've mattered much to me. Dobby enjoys a social life of paintballing, LARPing and going to gigs with mates, whereas Mark just wants to sit in his flat watching Babylon 5 with a prawn vindaloo. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Does it seem to anyone else that the way dobby died was; for lack of a better term the most "gruesome" or "realistic" death in the book. He was scrambling to find something to give him because he didn’t expect Dobby to give him a gift, not wanting to hurt Dobby’s feelings that he didn’t have something to give to him. and Dobby is meant to be the critique of humans / magical humans on other beings. To know the danger a stranger is in by attending the school, Dobby still had the courage to creatively try and keep him safe miserable is better than dead. I believe Snape died the most painful death. Dobby, is practically everyone's favorite character, yet he really gets the short end of the stick in the films. Dobby is a MUCH more important character in the books. He does pretty much the same thing all year until saved by Harry, another damsel in distress for the great boy who lived to save I Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. Oct 17, 2023 · Dobby's death is one of the most emotional scenes in the Harry Potter films as it highlights the bond between him and Harry. It is the absolute worst death because it was so innocent. I adore Dobby; he's in my top five favourite characters. In the books Dobby only said “Harry Potter” and then died right there in the movie Dobby had a lot more words and had a lot more of a impact in his death. But Dobby lived a good life and died a hero. It's devoid of emotion. As a Dobby, on the other hand, is determined to make all life (and death) worship the Great Master of Death Harry Potter. He had physical pain, unlike those who were killed instantly with a curse. I grew to love the way he acted and the way he would say that he would punish himself. Harry Potter's author knew what she was doing when she chose to kill off Dobby. In Hollows, by Aberforth's order, dobby goes to Malfoy manner to save life's of harry and friends, ultimate cause of his death. reminder that ron weasley put his socks on Dobby's feet when dobby died. Hurt way worse than Dumbledore's death. Edit: I’m stupid and forgot to mention: This is about the movies. To free Harry not from just the Death Eaters, or Voldemort, but from all the suffering he went through. When Dobby gives Harry the gillyweed 10 minutes before the task started and Harry would die, Dobby should've died. Sep 1, 2021 · Dobby's death does not only reflect the desire Harry's parents had to protect him but also echoes the death of Cedric Diggory in the Goblet of Fire. Hurt slightly more than Sirius' death. . I don't necessarily agree with changing Hedwig's death for the film,-- there's a reason it was so abrupt and unexpected in the books-- I just felt it harder in the movies because I wasn't as distracted by everything else. It's like so annoying, and the real reason i could see why they cut him out of the following films we'll discuss, is because they really didn't know any better, or better yet didn't know he would become such a huge and important character later down the line. However I did find Dobby annoying at first because I saw the first two movies before I read the books. Dobby's death is the saddest because they made us sit in it. When reading CoS and the reveal that he was the Malfoy's slave I immediately changed my thoughts on Dobby. Dobby's death taught me that it doesn't matter who you are, where you come from, you can be brave and do the right thing. I always disliked Dobby's death. Then the films forgets he exists for four movies. If I had to explain it, I guess in the It is the absolute worst death because it was so innocent. But Hagrid was the real " Dad" to Harry. Dying while saving others. That coupled with the fact the film was so widely seen and dobby has less screen time than filch's cat kind of made me think it's not so much of spoilerI struggled to think of anything else to call it, it's kinda the only thing you can D: A discussion on Reddit about the emotional impact of Dobby's death in the Harry Potter series. Sep 22, 2019 · Dobby’s death in Harry Potter was one of the most emotional moments from the book series, but the movies didn't do it justice. Moody's was the same way but we already kind of assumed he'd die anyway. His intentions may have been good in the grand scheme of things, but honestly Dobby had fuck all empathy or regard for the shit Harry was going through at home or that how much Hogwarts and his friends meant to him. He appears in books 2, 4,5,6, and 7, so Harry has much more of a relationship with him and the death hits him and the reader way harder. (Although I did cry for Dobby, I still wasn't surprised or anguished by it). The Order encounter the Death Eaters many times prior to Harry's birth. I can't seem to watch or read Sirius' death anymore. Sirius died pointlessly because Harry made a mistake. I realize he saved Harry's life and everyone was grateful for that, but the attention to his death was excessive. So did Fred, Dumbledore, Tonks and Remus. Ron cared about the passing of Dobby, but Hermione needed right now help. " I always interpreted this as the house elves had found out that Dobby had been killed at decided to revolt against the Death Eaters. If you get chosen for the tri wizard tournament you HAVE to participate otherwise you die. And when you listen to Stephen Fry's narration, it's even more emotional. And in so doing, free himself from the same. The scene in the movie had more emotion and hurt to watch and listen than reading it in the book. His death was very underwhelming and bland in the book then in the movie. dobby's death . But Slytherin's monster attacks muggle-borns, and Harry is not a muggle-born, so there's no reason for Dobby to think Harry will be a target. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. He didn't appear after that. His death scene, while effectively staged and filmed, didn't touch me emotionally. All he ever did was help people and he would do it with a smile on his face. I'm 24 freaking years old bawling and eating pizza rolls over the death Harry is responsible for Dobby's death, not because he asked Dobby to never save him again, but because he said Voldemort's name! Ron had come back by that point and let them know the name was cursed, he absolutely knew it would have consequences, but he was just so determined to prove Hermione wrong that he said it to be defiant. Harry's grief intensifies the emotional impact of the House Elf's Mar 18, 2024 · Dobby died from a knife in his chest thrown by Bellatrix Lestrange. He was annoying and got killed off for shock value. Many people say Dobby had the most painful death, but I disagree. I knew people would die in the book, and so no one's death affected me all that much. I never found Sirius' death that foreshadowed first time out. But I hate dobby the most. Needles to say, I cry every time I read that chapter but this time my dumb ass realized something I didn't before. I just have to skip it. Each and every death is so intense, I cry every time. In 1997, Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone marked the beginning of J. The amount of trouble he stirred up for Harry in the Chamber of Secrets, WHAT THE FUCK. He raises up an army of zombie house elves to ensure the world is cleaned of unbelievers and people who don't wear socks. His Dobby died helping to further a cause for someone he believed in, in the same way that the Battle of Hogwarts was pitched to provide cover for Harry to find the last Horcruxes. Voldemort still goes to hogwartz and asks for the allegence of everyone. And because of Dobby and Kreacher, Ron finally understands the importance of the house elves leading to Ron and Hermione's first kiss. Nov 16, 2021 · Redditor VMNC presents another unpopular perspective when he states that Dobby's death was necessary for the plot to make sense. In the films Dobby appears in Chamber of Secrets where he is critical to the plot. The movie just had him Stunned by Dobby which was probably because his death was too gruesome for the big screen. How self-less! Yuck, the execution was terrible. He strangled himself with his magical hand, while Ron and Harry and he himself struggled to try to get the hand off him. The first time we see Dobby, he basically hurts himself, then gets Harry in trouble. I’ve never liked Dobby. Dobby would have become "a get-out-of-jail-free card for the entire rest of the plotline" and Harry and the others would have been able to communicate easily with the Order without the Death Eaters or Voldemort being able to trace them. I was sad for Harry and the others, but otherwise it was just a plot point. Most deaths happen in the middle of other things happening. Many wish to die that way when their time comes. I don’t like any of the house elves, to be honest. The strength it took for Dobby to do what he did to try and keep Harry from Hogwarts was a testament to his character. Harry should have never have helped Dobby obtain freedom. Despite Cedric and Harry being pitted against The war with Voldemort and the Death Eaters started in 1970s and when Snape graduated in 1978 he immediately joined the Death Eaters. I agree with the naming one. Just imo Dobby was sadder. K Rowling’s stories set in the Wizarding World, which culminated in 2007 with the publishing of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. In the movies, no. Only thing that helps me with Dobby's death is his speech. However, I know many people who really don't enjoy him. it looks like In wizarding world breaking any promise might have some serious consequences. What I'm getting at is that dobby died in the most muggle way in the entire series, being killed by a knife just seems to me to be a very non magical way to die. Later during the deathly hollows, Dobby saves Harry Potter's life and in doing so breaks his promise. Dobby wasn’t trying to kill but instead protect. Only some deaths are incredibly captured by the movies, take Sirius' for example. So, I was re-reading DH for the umpteenth time and reached Dobby's death. Here lies Dobby. It's possible to care about two things but only act on one. They defended their masters by using kitchen knives to stab at the attackers' ankles. He had nothing to gain and everything to lose, he stood up directly to his oppressors who abused him, the very people who scared the shit out of him, to do the right thing. Dobby doesn’t care that they’re Uncle Vernon’s old socks, he just cares that they’re Harry Potter’s socks and that Harry Potter gave them to him. And maybe, at the end, Harry knew that's what Dobby was trying to do. No time to grieve, got to keep moving. Snape quickly became one of Voldemort's most trusted Death Eater (if not most trusted). In COS Harry made dobby promise not to come and try to save his life. I'm grateful to JKR for treating Fred and George like two people who are able to be separated. Dobby is powerful, loyal and constantly underestimated. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, take classes with our fine Hogwarts staff, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best, and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. In The Deathly Hallows, Dobby sneaks into Malfoy Manor in order to save Harry, Ron Weasley, Hermione Granger, Garrick Mar 13, 2022 · Irrespective of the unpopular opinions by Harry Potter fans on Reddit, Dobby had been a loyal friend to Harry. Several pages were devoted to the mourning and burial of the elf, whereas other important characters had less than a paragraph. I was rewatching the Harry Potter series and at the end of the second movie Harry says to Dobby, Promise me that you will never try to save my life again. I'm 24 freaking years old bawling and eating pizza rolls over the death Maybe Dobby knew sacrificing his life could save and help heal Harry. The final words he said were, very aptly, almost an ode to the Boy Wizard who held him as he breathed his last. Sirius died in the middle of battle. It was pure movie trope. As a twin: Fred. Before Fred's death, I was always like "well, that was expected". Hedwig was a pet/ mail carrier. “Dobby must do it, for Harry Potter’s own Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. A Free Elf. They think he's squeaky and annoying. The Potter soon after joined the Order of the Phoenix. I bawl my eyes out every time I watch the Dobby death scene, but I did find him very annoying in CoS lol. Right after freeing him, Harry convinces Dobby to set his special bludgers on the free Death Eaters, starting with Malfoy Sr. hmmm, well you have to then realize he should've died in Goblet of Fire. I can’t put a finger on why though. But Dobby is much more comfortable in her skin that Mark is, whereas he feels he should hide away his geekiness and instead be into sensible hobbies like World War II and John Ruskin. However, in the books you see way more of Dobby, and while I still found him kinda annoying, you also get more respect for him, so his death becomes more effective. so I still absolutely love Dobby, even if he was getting on my (and Harry's) nerves early on It is the absolute worst death because it was so innocent. They shoved him back into the story in film 7, only to exploit his death for cheap emotional poignancy in the same movie. His death didn't help a cause and it wasn't heroic. aoqhutvtcnednpbqpntkaevpyhmqtqhqiopiyuykxldnpjjogwg